Israeli-American Woman Makes Controversial Promise to Spouse Amidst War: Another Child in Exchange for Not Joining the Fight


Title: Balancing Love, Loyalty, and Parenthood in Times of Conflict

Dear Amy,

I find myself caught in a complex web of emotions and promises, and I’m hoping you can shed some light on this delicate situation. As an Israeli-American wife, I’m faced with the heart-wrenching decision of whether to ask my husband to refrain from going to fight in a war, with the promise of expanding our family as a bargaining chip.

The weight of this promise hangs heavy over our heads, as it intertwines our desires for both peace and parenthood. On one hand, I yearn for the safety and well-being of my husband, fearing the potential consequences of him joining the battle. On the other hand, I can’t help but question the morality and fairness of using the prospect of another child as a means to dissuade him from fulfilling his patriotic duty.

This predicament raises broader questions about the intersection of love, loyalty, and parenthood, especially in times of conflict. How do we navigate the complexities of our personal desires and the obligations we feel towards our country and loved ones? Is it ethical to make such a promise, knowing the potential consequences it may have for our relationship and our future family?

I’m torn between wanting to protect my husband and longing for the peaceful future we envision as parents. Amy, what advice can you offer to help us find a compromise that honors both our commitment to each other and our sense of duty?

A conflicted Israeli-American spouse

Dear Amy,

I am writing to seek your advice on a delicate matter that has recently come up in my marriage. I am an Israeli-American man, and my wife is also Israeli-American. We have been married for five years and have a beautiful three-year-old daughter together.

As you may be aware, tensions and conflicts in our home country have escalated, and there is a possibility of a war breaking out. Given my dual citizenship, there is a chance that I may be called upon to serve in the Israeli military.

My wife, who is understandably concerned about my well-being and the potential dangers of war, recently made a surprising promise to me. She said that if I choose not to go fight in the war, she will have another child with me.

This proposition has left me feeling conflicted and torn. On the one hand, I love my wife and value my family deeply. The idea of having another child together is something I have always wanted. On the other hand, I also feel a strong sense of duty towards my home country and a responsibility to protect it.

I am struggling to come to a decision, as I don’t want to disappoint my wife or neglect my duty as a citizen. I understand her concerns, but I am also aware of the potential consequences of not fulfilling my obligations.

I wanted to seek your advice on how to approach this situation. Is it fair for my wife to make such a promise? Should I prioritize my family over my duty to my country? How can we find a compromise that satisfies both our desires?

Any guidance or insights you can provide would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you,

Conflicted Husband

Leave a Comment